Arizona

Sales Associate

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Pacesetter

Pursuit of Excellence

Mesa, AZ

Online

Pacific Region Virtual Agents

This review made our day! I’m so glad you had a good experience. If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team in Mesa AZ!

Friendly, knowledgeable, efficient. Prompt in returning calls. Will continue to work with him.

I’m so grateful for your kind words, Claire. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.

Excellent service and very knowledgeable. Told him my needs and he delivered the best priced insurance. It was such an easy process. Very happy to have an agent that cares like Casey does.

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review. I’m so glad you had a good experience. If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team in Mesa AZ!

Thank you so much for you! Casey Payne I highly appreciate all the help you provided and guidance. Determined to get me with the best  quote policy. You’re the best!!! Thank you again. Have a wonderful day!

Had an issue with my insurance where it automatically cancelled without being notified. He went out of his way to contact the proper people to override the error and reinstate my insurance without missing a beat. 

I recently purchased my first Subaru ever and I absolutely love it! I needed to find perfect auto/home insurance. Thanks to Subaru they had Casey Payne give me a call, he shopped around and gave me info I never even knew about as a matter of fact I’m sure a lot of us never new about. He sure did save me some cash and was very very helpful. Thank you Casey!

Casey was super helpful and got me the best rate!

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review. If you have additional needs or questions, please reach out!

I needed to upgrade/change my home and auto insurance and linked up with Casey Payne today.
Casey knows exactly what we need in getting the best insurance upgrade.
I highly recommend him for anyone considering any type of  similar insurance policy change.
Call him on any questions you may have
He will get your questions answered.

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review. I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services. If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team in Mesa AZ!

I was referred to Casey by my son-in-law to work on Lowering my car and house insurance.   He worked on it and reduced my insurance by $650.00.  I’m a retired Police Officer living on a fixed income and anytime I can save money it’s a plus.  Another great benefit is he’s a phone call away if I have any questions.

Hi Blanca S, thanks for leaving such a positive review! If you have friends who need insurance, please send them to this outstanding team in Mesa AZ!

Casey was able to save me quite some money on my auto and home insurance. He is very responsive and looks out for what’s best for you. Additionally, he was extremely patient while explaining everything and respected my time (aka he’s not a nagging salesman). I’d definitely recommend to my family and friends.

Loved working with Casey. He was very personable and got us the best possible quote. Thanks Casey great job!!

Casey Payne reviewed our Home, auto and umbrella policies. Many of us use an insurance company for years, and not consider that an agent/ broker will find a company that fits your specific insurance needs, and as time passes our specific needs for insurance change a great deal.
Casey has the experience, and resources to review options, make sure you are well insured, and in my case save thousands of dollars per year over all. Proper coverage is "peace of mind" saving money as well, that is a job well done, thank you.
Jeff Grimm and Family

We have been working with Casey for over 12 yrs and he has always done his best to make sure we have the correct coverage as well price and not jeopardize quality.

Such an amazing experience with Casey. I have never used an insurance broker before but from here on out I will always call him. He is extremely knowledgeable and definitely can get you the best deal out there. He’s patient and understands you have questions and he will answer them. Top notch customer service and saved me thousands.

Such an amazing experience with Casey. I have never used an insurance broker before but from here on out I will always call him. He is extremely knowledgeable and definitely can get you the best deal out there. He’s patient and understands you have questions and he will answer them. Top notch customer service and saved me thousands.

Thank you again Casey 

Answers phone and answers questions immediately! 

Casey has been our insurance broker for many years and has been fantastic. He is always willing to spend the time to discuss your options/coverages and answer all your questions. Highly recommend!

Very patient and knowledgeable.  Wound up saving me over $1000 a year for as good if not better insurance

Today I had a great experience working with Casey Payne he found me almost $1600 in savings on home and car insurance!! Thank you!

This review made our day! I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services.

Hi Geoffrey Heard, thanks for leaving such a positive review! I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Casey is Exceptional!!! He takes time to work with the customer to find the policy(ies) that fit their needs and budget. He is honest and caring at the same time. I had an absolute great experience and he saved me a whole lot of money on my home, auto and life insurance policies!!

Hi Bryan, that's great to hear! I’m so glad you had a good experience. I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Casey worked late into the evening to get me the best deal possible.  Great insurance agent that cares about his customers.

Hi, Mary! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this amazing review. I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Great new agent for me.  Took all the time necessary to help me with all my insurance needs.  I would recommend to everyone. 

Valerie M, I'm so glad you had a good experience. I look forward to serving your insurance needs for years to come!

I appreciate Casey’s professionalism and patience in explaining the new coverage, which was financially beneficial. 

Hi Dale, that's great to hear! I appreciate the fantastic review and am glad I could be of service. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Casey is always on top of my insurance policy! Always ready to help with any changes that come along. Friendly and professional!

Hi David, that's great to hear! I appreciate the fantastic review and am glad I could be of service. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Casey was very helpful with my insurance needs and got me the best deal possible.  He actually alerted me of a major increase of my homeowners premium and contacted me to let me know.  He then went to work to find me better rates on both my homeowners and auto policies. Thank you!

Dylan B., we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Casey is great. Saved me over 50$ on my auto insurance. Knowledgable. I’m paying practically the same amount for an almost brand new truck that I was for my 20 yr old truck with his help.

A true professional, worked to get me the best rates possible.  I have 2 homes and 3 vehicles and Casey used multiple companies to get me the absolute lowest rates. I highly recommend Chase for all insurance needs.

Hi Bryan, I appreciate the fantastic review! I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Casey is very responsive and does everything in his power to get the best coverage and premiums. He very personable and I recommend him highly.

I’m so grateful for your kind words, Ware F. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.

Casey is a fine person and I love working with him. 

Thank you, Cathy! Insurance is complicated. I love to help make it simple. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey is amazing! He is also very patient

Everyone knows what a pain insurance companies can be. However, if you work with Casey, everything will be smooth sailing and hassle free!

Hi Bobbie S, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Easy to work with and saved me about $1,000. I went with Progressive and got the best rate.

Hi Craig, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Wow! We just purchased a Subaru. The dealer recommended Casey for a review.  Casey saved us $160 dollars per month!  Great job Casey.

Hi Brent, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Enjoyed working with Casey regarding my insurance needs. He was able to provide me with vehicle, home and umbrella policies at very competitive rates.

Thank you, Jeff! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Thanks MJ and Casey.  Smooth transaction saving me money.  Auto and Renters Insurance as
well as quoting out an Umbrella Policy.  All good 😊👍🏼

Hi RikkiLynn, Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review.

Hi Sarah, I appreciate the fantastic review! I work hard to exceed expectations and I'm thrilled you had a good experience.

Fast and convenient service, and the best rates. Definitely recommend!

Hi Eddie, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey took the time offered me a hugh savings with my auto and home insurance. Beating a competitor that I thought was a good savings. Explained everything well and same coverage for way less. A 6K a year savings!

Hi Jarod, I appreciate the fantastic review! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Casey was great and very informative looking for the best rates.

Hi Blake, that's great to hear! I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Casey was easy to work with and provided great customer service. He got me a policy that I was happy with

Thank you, Jared! I appreciate the fantastic review and am glad I could be of service. I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services.

Casey has always been knowledgeable and very responsive.  I have used him for 10yrs plus for all of my Insurance needs and have been very happy with the service! 

Hi Tamera, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey was amazing and got me an incredible rate very professional!

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this amazing review. I work hard to exceed expectations and I'm thrilled you had a good experience. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Great guy to work with. He used  lot of his personal time to resolve an issue with my new vehicle VIN number. Other agencies could not or would not do so. Even the dealership could not resolve it! He did with a lot of time and effort.
AND… he set me up with an automobile policy which is FAR below cost elsewhere! I am grateful and impressed!

Hi Ishiah, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey was incredibly helpful and is clearly skilled at what he does! As first time insurance holders, our quoted price from another company was originally sky high. We were pleasantly surprised at what he was able to get for us!!

We are super happy and grateful for the services provided and I highly recommend Casey Payne to be selected for your insurance needs. :)

I’m so grateful for your kind words, Jessica. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community. My job is to advise you on all your insurance needs and I am so pleased I could do that. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Working with most insurance agents gives me anxiety, because it seems like everyone just wants to push a commission. Casey was courteous and knowledgeable in order for me to make a financial decision that was best for my life. Thank you for being respectful and professional! I would recommend this company to anyone.

Eric Bloom, I am so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!

Hi Marc, thanks for leaving such a positive review! When my customers are happy, I am too. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey does a great job. He's quick to respond and truly cares about his customers. He has a wide variety of options available... give him a call. You will be impressed!!

George, we are so glad that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you for your business!

Hi Harry Wijnveldt, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

Casey Payne was very helpful to find great deals for all three of my insurance policies.
Due to his efforts I saved a lot of money and got great deals.
I really recommend Casey Payne as insurance agent.

Hi Jane Konrad, thanks for leaving such a positive review! I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services. Insurance is complicated. I love to help make it simple. I look forward to helping you again in the future.

I am so grateful to my car salesman for giving me Casey’s name! He was available, called me back in a timely manner, and found amazing rates for my new car!  It only took less than an hour to find me much better rates! Call him and you will also save money!

Hi, David Watson! My job is to advise you on all your insurance needs and I am so pleased I could do that. Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.

What a great find!! Casey has been amazing to work with. He's definitely a advocate for the consumer looking to improve your insurance position and reduce your costs

Hi Jeff Kneisley, that's great to hear! I appreciate you taking the time to let us know about your experience! Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Casey was very helpful and through. He took great care of my needs and made sure I was taken care of

Hi Sharon D, that's great to hear! When my customers are happy, I am too. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Very grateful for the time Casey spent with me today. Turned a stressful situation for me into something simple and comfortable. 

Hi Kailee, that's great to hear! I’m thrilled that you are satisfied with our services. Please don't hesitate to contact me next time you want help with insurance.

Thanks for saving me 1k on my home insurance and making it a quick easy process =] with a positive experience.

Hi Glen, that's great to hear! I loved being of service to you and hope I can assist you again soon.

Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community. Your review means a lot to us and lets us know I’m on the right track!

Always so professional, helpful and responsive!

It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Casey was wonderful 👍🏼
Took his time to find me the lowest price at the same time using a reputable company 👍🏼Call Casey you will be glad you did, he saved me over $800, he’s the best💪🤩

Hi jan hooten, thanks for leaving such a positive review!

Great service, very professional.  A keeper!

Hi Kim Martin, thanks for leaving such a positive review!

Casey is a very awesome agent he has always worked with me and made sure I got a good rate on my insurance. Very friendly as well. I'm adding a big thank you for helping my kids with there insurance needs.

Hi Kailey Rae, that's great to hear! It was a pleasure working with you. I'm glad I could help you find the right insurance at the right price.

Casey saved me over $100 a month on my insurance :)

Casey has consistently guided me thru my insurance needs for the past several years, including my home and auto insurance! He is personable and is always respectful during the process of assessing my insurance needs!

I could get everything what I want to know timely. It really helped me to get nice car insurance !

Very helpful! Helped me every step of the way

Casey is very professional and patient! I'm excited to have him as my agent because I know he'll work in my best interest.

I received excellent customer service and very competitive quotes. Always received a call back in a timely manner. First insurance agent to discuss different policy benefits and what is truly needed. I highly recommend Casey 👍

Great to hear!  We are so glad you had a good experience.

Casey is most knowledgeable and truly out to assist his clients with insurance needs in every situation. He has given me outstanding service and information in all the years I have had insurance with him.

Long term working with Casey. Helpful, efficient. Would definitely recommend.

Casey was very attentive, explained some things that I didn't understand about my policy.  Searched for the right  policy for me.  Very happy today for his help.

Casey delivers superior service! He is thorough, personable & listens to what I have to say. Casey has superseded all of my expectations! Jeanne Haynes

This man get me like half the price I had for a car insurance and we got everything done in half an hour. Amazing.

Casey Payne is amazing. He literally helped me save more than 300 bucks in a less than 20 mins phone call. Really helpful and professional.

Maribel was incredible to work with, she’s been able to save my family and I so much on insurance. I can always trust to not waste anytime whenever I call since she’s great at helping us out. It’s clear she’s knowledgeable and answers any questions I may have in a clear and easy to understand way.

Thank you for following up with us this weekend. We appreciate you finding the lowest rate for our car insurance as well.

Wonderful experience using Casey to get my insurance set! Helped get it taken care of and jumped through a lot of hoops to help me out, highly recommend him!

Casey was very helpful in finding an insurance that had coverages I needed at a great rate. Outstanding and knowledgeable service.

I’m very happy with Casey Payne as as my insurance agent, he is accessible, extremely knowledgeable, will take the time to answer any questions, which is rare in this day and age, I highly recommend Casey.

Casey was super helpful and was even able to combine my auto and homeowners insurance under the same company which saved me money.

Casey has been our agent for many years.  I trust him completely with all my insurance needs.  In addition, he has been a great agent for our adult children.  He is the best in the business!

Totally recommend Casey!!! Fast to sign up and saved us so much money!!! He’s the man for sure for all your insurance needs!!!

Casey takes the work out of shopping for car insurances, has great recommendations for coverages based on your own personal needs, always follows up the same day, and provides excellent customer service.

Casey is the best!   He makes it so easy to help find the best and most affordable coverage.   I'm super busy and it's a quick phone call to him and he takes care of everything for me, It would take me hours trying to collect all the quotes and I'm able to get it done directly with him in minutes.

CASEY Payne was vert professional and so easy to work with plus he saved us lots of money!

Casey Payne is an outstanding insurance agent. He listens to your questions and gets you the exact coverage you need. I highly recommend contacting Casey for your insurance needs!

Casey made the whole process quick and easy while saving me money.

I loved that Casey was able to shop my rates with multiple (like 30) other companies and because of that I got an amazing rate. My new rate was half of what I was paying previously. I also decided to invest in the future of myself and my family by investing in life insurance through him because it was so affordable. Highly recommend!!

Casey is very helpful and shared a great deal of knowledge!

Casey found me the cheapest insurance rate on a 2022 Subaru WRX. I was getting quoted 100+ more a month than what Casey found. Couldn’t be happier after hearing I wouldn’t have to spend a car payment on insurance. All within a 7 minute phone call as well.

Lead Insurance Agent

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent

Your local Comparion agents offer expert assistance to get the right vehicle coverage that fits your needs and budget, no matter what you're driving.

Vehicle

Whether you rent or own, protect your home and belongings from damage or loss by talking to a local Comparion agent today.

Property

The things that are the most important to us require the best protection. Rest easy with the right life insurance and other specialty coverage.

Life and other

We appreciate your review and for taking the time to let us know about your experience!

Great experience with Casey. Worked with my schedule.

Casey is the best insurance agent! He gives you his cell phone number so you can reach him whenever. I am so grateful that he was able to save me so much money. I highly recommend him! 

Hi Courtney R, thanks for leaving such a positive review!

I had a wonderful experience with Casey. He was friendly and knowledgeable and took the time to go over all of my options for my car, renters, and even life insurance. He gives out his cell phone so he is always available. He responded quickly and was even available to answer my questions via text message on a Saturday morning. Additionally, he was able to save me a lot of money too. I highly recommend him for any insurance needs!

Great to hear and thank you for leaving a positive review!

Casey was awesome. Really took his time to explore every option to get me the best coverage and price. Saved me a lot of money! Very friendly and professional. 

Thank you for sharing your review, even if negative.

Horrible service. Dude never replies. Lied about finding me coverage. Scammed someone else I know. DO NOT USE HIM. 

Casey has been our agent for over 15+ years. We got great deals on our property, umbrella and car insurance. If we ever have a question even if it's late or a weekend he's there to help us. He always goes above and beyond for us. We definitely recommend Casey Payne for your insurance needs.

Really helpful and knowledgeable. I also appreciated how quickly he responded and helped me find insurance. Definitely recommend!

Casey is a great agent. He'll call you back in a timely manner. And, He finds you the best rates for insurance.

Thank you for your review and for taking the time to leave a great compliment.

Casey was incredibly helpful in providing me my quote and the required effort on my part was minimal. He made the whole process quite manageable given my busy schedule.

Thank you for your positive review and providing feedback.

I had a wonderful experience with Casey. He was friendly and knowledgeable and took the time to go over all of my options for both my car and renters insurance. He responded quickly and was even available to answer my questions on a Saturday morning. Additionally, he was able to save me a lot of money too. I highly recommend him for any insurance needs!

Casey always does a phenomenal job keeping us informed on our policy’s, and making sure we receive the best rates! Thank you Casey!

Nick Dudley, thank you for letting us know about this. Your feedback helps us get better

Rates are fine, but he never responds or replies and is completely inaccessible after he gets your business. Very unprofessional.

Casey Payne

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent | Mesa, AZ

Quote with Casey

Location

1620 S Stapley Dr
Ste 120
Mesa, AZ 85204

About me

Licensed in

Arizona - 911592

California - 4271888

Colorado - 780479

Georgia - 3753391

Indiana - 3993804

Services

Car insurance

Home insurance

Umbrella insurance

Life insurance

Insurance consulting

Languages

English

Education

Arizona State University

Awards & Honors

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Pacesetter

Pursuit of Excellence

Reviews

Casey Payne

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent | Mesa, AZ

Quote with Casey

Location

1620 S Stapley Dr Ste 120 Mesa, AZ 85204

About me

Licensed in

Arizona - 911592

California - 4271888

Colorado - 780479

Georgia - 3753391

Indiana - 3993804

Services

Car insurance

Home insurance

Umbrella insurance

Life insurance

Insurance consulting

Languages

English

Education

Arizona State University

Awards & Honors

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Pacesetter

Pursuit of Excellence

Reviews

1620 S Stapley Dr
Ste 120
Mesa, AZ 85204