Senior Agent

Comparion Lead Insurance Agent

Executive Agent

Comparion Insurance Agent

Agent

We're ready to offer personalized advice and quotes on auto, home, life, pet, and more.

Your local Comparion agents offer expert assistance to get the right vehicle coverage that fits your needs and budget, no matter what you're driving.

Vehicle

Whether you rent or own, protect your home and belongings from damage or loss by talking to a local Comparion agent today.

Property

The things that are the most important to us require the best protection. Rest easy with the right life insurance and other specialty coverage.

Life and other

Pennsylvania

At the Comparion office in Exton, trained local agents can help you find the coverage you need, and the discounts you deserve. Our Exton office is located In the North Point Office Building.
Our office proudly serves all of southeastern Pennsylvania, including West Chester, Downingtown, Exton and Coatesville.
Causes close to our hearts
Our representatives volunteered locally with the Rebuild Together Philadelphia program.
Talk to a Comparion Agent Today
Contact a sales representative today to learn more about which auto insurance, home insurance, and life insurance options are best for you and your family.

Exton, PA

I just purchased a new car and the dealership recommended using Comparion Insurance Agency to compare insurance prices.  It was a pleasure to work with Preston Neidermyer who saved me thousands of dollars on my car, home, and umbrella policies.  When he first quoted me my new price I thought he had to be mistaken but once he confirmed it again, I just could not believe it.  It was a pleasure to work with Preston Neidermyer and would highly recommend him for your insurance needs.

Just had my recent renewal for my auto & home insurance that Preston Neidermyer had helped me with a year ago. The premium WENT DOWN. Absolutely incredible! Thank you Preston!

Preston Neidermyer at Comparion Insurance in Exton is the real deal. He helped me compare multiple carriers and saved me hundreds on my auto and home insurance. Fast, honest, and super knowledgeable. If you’re in Exton or anywhere near Philly, talk to Preston before you renew your policy!

Michael Pennyman was straight forward, knowledgeable, and friendly to speak with throughout the process of switching my auto insurance plan.  I now have better coverage and a much better monthly rate.  I am grateful and I'm an extremely satisfied customer!!:))  Thank you, Michael!

I got my insurance through Michael Pennyman, and it was really easy. :)

Michael Pennyman is the best insurance sales person I have ever worked with.  His dedication to providing excellent service is exceptional.  Michael has always been willing to work internal issues, escalate and basically do what needs to be done to meet the customers needs when he believes the insurance company is not performing for the customer.  I highly recommend him as a sales rep to work with.

I have worked with Michael Pennyman from this company for my home insurance needs. He has been nothing but professional and helpful. I appreciate that he does what you ask of him and doesn't try to upsell you on the products like other agents or companies. I would work with him and Comparion again for my insurance needs.

Excellent service! Allison is very informative & always helpful with our insurance needs. I appreciate all she does to help.

I am very satisfied with excellent service anda suport needed.

Colleen was very helpful reviewing my family policies and life insurance. I highly recommend

Coleen is professional and always a pleasure to work with.  She promptly responded  to all  of my  emails and phone calls. She took the time to explain everything in detail as well. Outstanding customer service and saved me and my family money.  Highly recommend her services.

Colleen was so helpful when it came to reviewing my insurance policies. She was always available for any questions I may have had. I highly recommended her for all of your insurance needs.

I switched over to Colleen a few months ago and she made it such a smooth transition! I bought a new vehicle recently and reached out to her and she took care of everything, switching over my insurance, with my new married name, SO QUICKLY! My husband is even switching all his policies over to Colleen as well. She is super knowledgeable, answers all questions, no matter how silly, and just makes it SO EASY! Thank you so much Colleen for everything! 100% Recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, and friendly agent!

Andrew Tomes is the guy! Great worker with positive energy and really put in the time with me to help lower my insurance by 100$.  Communicated with me from beginning to end 💯

Colleen Cavalieri is the best agent I ever had.  She went out of her way to help me with getting insurance on her day off without any hesitation when I needed help.  She has always been attentive and helpful to get the best insurance.  She goes above and beyond to help.  I truly highly recommend her!

Colleen Calvalieri made the transition to my new auto and home bundle easy and hassle free!  She was there every step of the way, explaining the process and answering any questions that I had . I’m so pleased with the whole experience and happy to have her as my agent.

I recently had a great experience working with Andrew Tomes, who helped me save money on my life insurance, auto insurance, and home insurance policies, and even got my dog Auggie a plan for pet insurance.
When I first contacted Andrew, I was concerned about the cost of my insurance policies and whether I was getting the best value for my money. Andrew took the time to review my policies and was able to find me better deals that saved me a significant amount of money each month. He was knowledgeable and professional throughout the process, and I really appreciated his attention to detail and willingness to answer all of my questions.
In addition to helping me save money on my insurance, Andrew was also able to help me find a great plan for my dog Auggie's pet insurance. As a pet owner, it's important to me to make sure that Auggie is covered in case of any unexpected medical expenses. Andrew was able to recommend a plan that was affordable and provided the coverage we needed.
Overall, I'm really happy with the services that Andrew provided and would highly recommend him to anyone who is looking for help with their life, auto, home or pet insurance. He was friendly, professional, and really went above and beyond to help me find the best options for my needs. Thanks again, Andrew!

Michael Penny man is a fine Salem, he's always responding to my need insurance question ⁉️

I’ve always had a great experience with Allison from Comparion! Allison has the time temperament and training to ensure you are properly educated on your protection options!

I’ve been trying to lower my car insurance rate for the past year. I’ve talked to several different companies and nobody could help me. I talked to Andrew Tomes and within 5 mins he found me better coverage and a lower rate. I can’t say enough good things about him and Liberty Mutual. Andrew was super helpful, personable and knowledgeable. If you need help with your insurance give him a call!!

Andrew Tomes is impressive and has great communication! I was having challenges with my previous agent/insurance due to lack of communication and education on my policy. He’s extremely professional and can help you find what works best for you. He’s also dedicated and is there whenever you need him. He was able to fill my gaps and was able to save me some $$ when I combined policies with my partner. Thanks for working with me!

I personally have worked with David Schultz, and he is absolutely remarkable! About a year and a half ago I started shopping around for insurance because my State Farm policy increased significantly. I spoke to numerous brokers and also called numerous insurance companies personally to get quotes. I could not find anything that was affordable. I was super stressed out and almost in tears. To my surprise I got a call from someone I did not even contact and that was David Schultz. I explained my situation, and he promised that he would not give up until he was able to find me an affordable policy. I was shocked when he called me back the following day and had a policy that was a half the cost  of what everyone else quoted me. I immediately signed up. When it was coming close to that policy renewing as it was a six month term David took it upon himself to continue to shop around and even got me a better rate! That is the first time I have ever experienced an insurance agent going above and beyond for their client, ensuring that I got the best deal available. And the coverage is amazing! More than I could ever expect! He has helped me so much that I have referred some of my patients, my family, my friends, and my colleagues!! David has also worked diligently to get them policies and has save them hundreds of dollars! YOU ARE SPECTACULAR DAVID AND FANTASTIC AT WHAT YOU DO!! THANK YOU FOR ALL OF YOU HARD AND AMAZING WORK!! I really look forward to working with you for the years to come and will continue to refer as many people as I can to you personally. You truly are the best!

We had a horrible experience with our previous insurance carrier. It was wonderful to have an agent like Colleen Cavalieri from Liberty Mutual to be so attentive and helpful. We are so glad we made the switch to a very competent agent and highly recommend her!

Best insurance company ever. My guy Andrew saved me hundreds and set me up with an amazing life insurance policy!

Colleen was excellent to work with. She helped us with our home and auto insurance work was very quick and efficient!! I have passed her name along to friends and she has helped them also and they are very happy!!! 😊

Love these guys. They always come through and help get our customers amazing rates. I can’t count how many times Andrew Tomes has bailed us out of a jam. Great team to work with for sure!

I have zero complaints!!! Andrew Tomes really helped me out. I even ended up saving a boat load of money :)

Colleen was so very helpful when getting me a quote on my insurance. She was kind with all the questions I had and she fully explained everything to me without making me feel like an inconvenience.

I was able to get help from Andrew Tomes this past weekend. As far as insurance goes I wasn’t as educated and going other places I felt like I didn’t know what I was getting. Andrew helped explain all that in detail and I was more confident then ever and he even saved me a couple of bucks with my new plan.

Andrew Tomas was extremely helpful with answering all of my questions in finding the best insurance for me. Thank you!

Andrew is the reason I refer 10-20 clients a month to this company, I will follow him whenever he goes.

After going from Geico to progressive when they provided a better rate I was shocked to find my premium go up hundreds of dollars for apparently no reason. I had no tickets, accidents and with only two used cars on the plan with honestly very little value. All reason to expect a normal increase but, not by over 10%. I contacted Jeff Sabalski who was not only professional but, answered all my questions, easy going and provided several quotes. I ended up buying the exact insurance I had for several hundred dollars less through him with liberty mutual and home owners insurance. Over all I was very happy with everything Comparison Insurance did and the work Jeff put into dealing with me.

Maureen Felizzi Swartz is the most professional and experienced insurance agent that I’ve ever worked with! I’ve followed her throughout her growing career, and I will not deal with any other agents. I’ve interviewed other agents. I have personally done extensive research on my own with other resources. Maureen has been the most knowledgeable and helpful! You absolutely won’t regret having her help for your insurance needs! She’s 100% the BEST!!!

Colleen Cavalieri was amazing to work with! She helped save us $$ on multiple policies and made the process extremely easy. She’s also helped several of my friends & clients!

Truly appreciated Colleen taking the time to look over my auto and renter's insurance. She was able to save me almost 300.00 a year.
She is consistent, professional, and knowledgeable. She is also patient and will take the time to explain something you don't understand. You don't see that often enough.
She even went above and beyond one evening when I needed my insurance information and couldn't locate it. She answered my text within minutes and emailed my information within the hour.
I happily recommend her to anyone who is shopping for insurance.

Andrew Tomes was the most personable, patient and HELPFUL insurance agent I have come across to date. Extremely knowledgeable about his focuses on life insurance specifically. As well as being a genuine kind person who understands the complexity of people’s real life situations and is willing to work with a client even on a complicated schedule. You guys got a good one in him. Thank you for your time and support Andrew!

Andrew was so helpful, knowledgeable, and truly had his best interest out for me. If you’re looking to get a great life insurance policy go to Andrew!!

After three days of receiving quotes for my car insurance I gave andrew a call & he helped me out tremendously with not only getting my rate down, but with significantly better coverage. He also talked me through a few different life insurance options and showed how much value life insurance can provide while I’m alive! He was extremely personable and made the process very simple. He has my highest recommendation.

I’ve always been intimated with getting started on insurance & proper ways to save, but then I met Andrew. Andrew was a huge help with me and educated me on how insurance operates and all the benefits that come with it. I highly recommend anybody looking for insurance to reach out to Andrew Tomes!!!

Andrew T. is just the best insurance agent around. Andrew has helped my mom and I both save money by changing auto insurance policies through the company, explained the perks of having life insurance with patience and is always available at any time to answer any questions we've had at any step along the way. He has a special charm and we can't rave about our new policies enough. If you are thinking of making the switch - do it!

Colleen Calverlli was super helpful with the process of picking the right insurance!! I would highly recommend her to anyone!! She even helped us save money!! She is the best!

Colleen Cavalieri our agent is amazing! We have had to reach out to her so many times and she always goes out of her way to get us the answers we need in a timely and professional way! I highly recommend her!

Allison is great to work and makes sure all your needs are met!

Matt was great in finding me the best insurance rate out there.  His customer service and response time
Is second to none.  I would strongly recommend Matt and his team for your insurance needs

Allison is awesome.  You will be in good hands with her!

I went to the local Exton office and the staff was friendly and personable. It was a great experience and I saved a ton on my auto and home insurance.

I had a very strange situation that insurance company's don't normally deal with regarding my car title. I don't have liberty mutual for insurance; however after speaking with Charita today and her giving her all to help me find the right person to help me further I will be considering liberty mutual in the future.. She was very professional and kind which is so very rare now-days.  Charita I truly appreciate you!

Steve Current is AMAZING at what he does. Even if he can't get you a policy he does everything he can to help you get a policy. He deserves an award for his dedication to customer service!!! I have never had such a positive experience purchasing an insurance policy!!! Steve you are such a wonderful person. Everything is so negative these days. It was a breath of fresh air dealing with you!! Liberty Mutual is blessed to have you representing them.

The safe driving rewards program is a scam.

Comparion Insurance Agency
Exton, PA

Quote with an insurance agent in Exton, PA

About the Exton, PA office

Comparion Insurance Agency Exton, PA

Quote with an insurance agent in Exton, PA

About the Exton, PA office

Comparion Insurance Agency
Exton, PA