Pennsylvania

Sales Associate

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Countrywide Rookie of the year

President's Club

Agent Digital Scorecard Top 100

Fast Start

Philadelphia, PA

Online

Mid-Atlantic Region Virtual Agents

Executive Agent

Comparion Executive Insurance Agent

Your local Comparion agents offer expert assistance to get the right vehicle coverage that fits your needs and budget, no matter what you're driving.

Vehicle

Whether you rent or own, protect your home and belongings from damage or loss by talking to a local Comparion agent today.

Property

The things that are the most important to us require the best protection. Rest easy with the right life insurance and other specialty coverage.

Life and other

Shayna Carnevale at Comparion Insurance Agency provided exceptional service and value. Her expertise in life insurance and property insurance was evident, and she made the process feel straightforward and trustworthy. I felt confident in the recommendations she offered, and the overall experience was positive. Highly recommend!

Five stars are not enough. She delivered an exceptional white-glove experience and exceeded my expectations in every way. Rather than simply providing quotes, she invested the time to truly understand my circumstances, what I was currently paying, the coverage that mattered most to me, and the documentation needed to perform a thorough analysis.

Thanks to her expertise, she was able to find me a significantly better insurance solution with lower costs and, in many cases, stronger coverage than I previously had. Throughout the entire process she was patient, proactive, detail-oriented, and incredibly knowledgeable. Her expertise, professionalism, and commitment to outstanding customer service set her apart.

If you're looking for someone who will advocate for you and deliver results, look no further.

Shayna and her team were awesome!!! They saved us a significant amount of money on both our homeowners and auto insurance polices and got us better coverage than we had with our previous insurance company for a fraction of the cost.

I’m very pleased with Shayna . She did an amazing job working with us and getting us the best deal we can. I would highly recommend her to other friends and family members.

Shayna was delightful to work with. She was very helpful throughout the whole process, explained everything in a way that was easy to understand, and made sure all of my questions were answered. She was patient, responsive, and genuinely cared about finding the best option instead of just trying to sell me something. If you’re looking for someone who’s knowledgeable and easy to work with, I’d definitely recommend Shayna.

I worked with Shayna for 16 years and Shayna and her team take the time to know you, and understand your needs. She returns calls quickly and makes sure her clients feel valued.

Shayna was awesome and very knowledgeable about getting homeowners insurance as a first time home buyer. She provided great information on the coverages i needed buying a house with an older roof. Highly recommend!

I cannot recommend Shayna and her team highly enough!

After reviewing my auto insurance, they were able to save me a substantial amount of money while making sure I still had the coverage I needed. Eli was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and made the entire process simple and stress-free from start to finish. Every question I had was answered promptly, and I never felt pressured or rushed into any decisions.

What impressed me most was that they took the time to look at my overall financial protection needs rather than just selling me a policy. Because of the savings they found on my auto insurance, we’re now exploring life insurance options as well.

It’s rare to find insurance professionals who genuinely put their clients’ best interests first, but that’s exactly what Shayna and her team do. If you’re looking for honest advice, great communication, and an agency that truly cares, I highly recommend reaching out to them!

I cannot recommend Shayna enough for all of your personal insurance needs! I recently switched my auto, homeowners, and life insurance policies over to her, and the entire process was seamless from start to finish.

She was incredibly responsive, thorough, and knowledgeable — she took the time to shop different options for me, explain everything clearly, and got comparisons back to me the very same day. Not only did she save me a significant amount of money, but she also helped me secure even better coverage for my family.

She also guided me through setting up a life insurance policy for my 22-year-old daughter, which gave me so much peace of mind. Shayna truly goes above and beyond for her clients and genuinely cares about helping people make the best decisions for their future.

If you’re looking for someone trustworthy, efficient, and easy to work with, I highly recommend reaching out to Shayna!

We reached out to Shayna to quote for auto insurance when we added a teen driver to our account and our auto insurance more than doubled! She was so thorough and answered all of our millions of questions. She was very helpful, patient, and knowledgable. I highly recommend working with her!

We just switched insurance companies thanks to Shayna. She was excellent from beginning to end. She kept us informed throughout the process. The best part is she saved us over $200 a month on our insurance. We would highly recommend her.

I was given Shayna Carnevale name through a friend who highly recommended her. She had purchased her pet insurance through Shayna. It was such a pleasure working with Shayna. I had so many questions, as I knew nothing about pet insurance. Shayna explained,in layman’s terms, coverages and my options and was able to answer all my questions. Also Shayna being a fellow pet owner, understood what we needed. It was such a pleasure working with Shayna and I will absolutely recommend her to my friends.

I highly recommend Shayna for any business owner! She and her team performed a comprehensive review of multiple commercial insurance policies for Wiz-Pro. Shayna and her specialized commercial team were incredibly thorough, reviewing an awful lot of paperwork to ensure every side of our business was covered properly. I really appreciated her straightforward and honest assessment—she provided great info on better pricing but also let us know when our current standing was already the best available. It’s rare to find a professional with this much integrity. Five stars for Shayna and her team’s expertise!

Shayna is absolutely wonderful to work with. She is warm, professional, and truly treats you like a family member from the moment you meet her. She provided a comprehensive review of my insurance, and it’s clear she is great at balancing both personal and professional needs. She went above and beyond for me, patiently reviewing an awful lot of policies (LOL!) to make sure my coverage was exactly where it needed to be. I really appreciated her honesty; she gave me clear information on potential better pricing but also let me know when I already had the best options available. If you want someone who is educated, honest, and treats your needs as their own, go see Shayna!

Great agent. Knows what she is doing.she will find you the right policy for your needs.

Shayna is terrific! Knowledgeable and caring.

Personal care. Thorough, caring and invested in your well being.  Shayna is the very best.  High integrity. Thank you for everything you’ve done for me, my family, and more to come. ❤️❤️❤️

Shayna is very knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with, very honest and won’t give you anything that won’t benefit you

Saved myself and family members a great deal of money when we needed insurance debit👍

Shayna's awesome! Customer service is impeccable.

Shayna is the best there is in the industry. She truly cares about her clients.  She is always available, no matter what and her response time is epic.  When I ask her to help me or handle something, she does it right away and I’m sure I can be problematic lol.  I refer her regularly and I know that they’ll be taking care of.  I’ll never use anyone else.  Thank you for all you do and most of all for who you are.

Robin Schnee

Shayna is very knowledgeable and has a large assortment of insurance carrier and products at her disposal. She was able to shop rates for me and find the best option for coverage and price. I highly recommend her.

Shayna was an absolute pleasure to work with! She went above and beyond to help me out and even saved me a significant amount of money. I’d highly recommend working with her — 10/10 experience!

Shayna took care of writing a life insurance policy for my wife after she struggled to be approved elsewhere. She provided an awesome life insurance policy with an added conversion option that gives the ability to shift the policy to long term care insurance if needed. We weren't even aware that existed! The benefits of working with Shayna are numerous. She will deliver all that you need efficiently, intelligently, and with a kindness that is unmatched in the industry!

I have had homeowners insurance with Shayna for over 5 years, for my private residence and a rental property. Shayna has always been very dependable. She has always returned my calls promptly and has kept in touch to update my policies for the best value. This year I was introduced to Elie Landon who is on Shayna’s team and he kept up the top notch service that I have expected from her team. Elie wanted all my insurances to be getting the best value, and to my surprise he even obtained an auto policy that was better than the one I had ( and I got the I had direct). When Elie did this for me he was able to bundle my policies and obtain a nice discount. It is great to have people like Shayna and Elie working hard to save me money. I would highly recommend both of these fine people along with Comparion Insurance Agency to look out for how I spend my hard earned money.

I've been a Liberty Mutual customer for over three decades.  Shayna Carnevale and Elie Landrin have been incredibly helpful, patient and caring over many years.  Infact they just saved me a few thousand dollars this year on my car insurance.  They are a great option for insurance.

Really grateful to Elie and Shayna for coming back to pursue me as a client. I really despise how hard it can feel to secure insurance these days and how much insurance companies steal from me, but working with them was really great. Elie helped me find new quotes and a deal that helped me save over $1,000 a year on home/auto insurance. They were also really helpful in offering me tips in the communicating the transition w/ my mortgage company. Hopefully next year when the insurance companies try and raise the rates again, they'll swoop in to find me better rates again.

Shayna was very knowledgeable and helpful with all my insurance needs. I would highly recommend her.

Shayna is very helpful and thorough. She will give you honest quotes without selling you something that you dont need, but she will make sure your  covered for the things you need

I wanted to acknowledge the ongoing professional services provided to me by my insurance agent Shayna Carnevale, at Comparion Insurance Company. She is very knowledgeable, and she pays close attention to the details that are most important to your specific needs. She works hard to make sure the right plan is cost effective so you get the most for your money. Her professional demeanor is a very valued asset that remains to be the core of her in every delivery. Her follow-up is unmatched, and I highly recommend her if you want the Best. I give her Ten Stars, because Five isn't enough. Comparion Insurance Company should be proud to have her as a part of their Team. She is outstanding, and I'm grateful for her continued services. Thank You Shayna Your The Best.

I am so grateful I got to connect with Shayna at Comparion Insurance Agency. It was an extreme pleasure conversing with an agent that is so professional and  passionate about her work. From the onset Shayna worked diligently investigating policies that would best meet my family's needs. She was incredibly helpful and answered all calls and questions promptly. Shayna walked me through the entire process with words of encouragement and patience. Elie, also part of her team, was  efficient, knowledgeable and most helpful as well.

Thanks to their excellent communication and willingness to go the extra mile we were able to do business together. I highly recommend their service to others.

I met Shayna a few years back when she visited my company to offer insurance to our team. At the time I was dedicated to my agent and chose not to make a change. I did however lock her contact information in my phone and am so glad I did. It’s been several years since we met and so much in the industry has changed. When I reached out to get a quote her response was immediate. Shayna understood my needs and I got a response within the hour. She gave me sound advice on a policy that met my needs then investigated further and helped me make a decision to better my policy. I recommend anyone searching for insurance to contact Shayna. She offers fair and trusting advice. I look forward to working with Shayna again when it’s time to renew my insurance. 

It's always a pleasure to sit down with Shayna and review our policies. Shayna wants to make sure you get the best coverage for your dollar as well as understanding your coverage limitations. Such a wonderful lady!

**UPDATE as of 1/15/2025**

Didn't give me an option to add a second review, so im just adding on to my first one.

We were shopping for Flood Insurance for our property and multiple companies said that the current price that we were paying could not be lowered and that it was the industry standard price.   We reached out to Shayna and explained this, and Shayna not only was able to find a lower price but one with a better price than what we had previously.  Shayna was able to find us one that was almost HALF of the price.

She went above and beyond to find us the coverage that we needed with a different company at a lower cost.

Thank you again!

Outstanding service and extremely knowledgeable on the products Shayna offers

Shayna is the best!! Besides her amazing knowledge of what she does, she is so personable, friendly and incredible to work with! Highly recommend!

I contacted Shayna by email for an insurance quote and she responded promptly. Within 24 hours I had my coverage! Very personable and professional. I will certainly continue to do business with her and I recommend her highly.

It has been my experience that you interact with your insurance agent when you first sign up with their company and unless you have an accident or issues you rarely communicate with them again. Shayna is not that type of agent. She has stayed in touch with me about any changes needed in my policies and when I did have a claim made sure it was followed through to the end. Likewise her associates are  equally responsive. This level of service is a desirable trait sought by people like myself who are loyalty driven to want to know their agent is working for them as well as the company. Shayna and her team, particularly Elie, are the people who make the company and why my children are also insured by her in their needs. It is not often that insurance comes up in neighborhood dicussions but when it does I'm never bashful about expressing my opinion about Shayna and Comparion. Thank you for letting me share. Rick

Been insuring me for close to 20 years and always does what’s best for her clients (and not just her family either!)

Shayna was extremely helpful and thorough. Would highly recommed.

Shayna has been exceptionally helpful with all my insurance needs.

My wife and I had spoken to several Insurance Agents looking to buy home owner's insurance for the first time and bundle our auto insurance. We were struggling with agents not explaining the information provided in quotes adequately. Shayna was recommended to me by my brother and there are three things she does tremendously well: 1) She is extremely fast in responding both via email and phone. 2) She explains all elements simply and in great detail when necessary. 3) She took interest in our unique needs and helped to adjust our policies accordingly. I learned more from Shayna in under a week than several weeks of working with other agents.

If I could give more stars I easily would! Shayna was incredible in helping me find a perfect pet insurance policy for my new puppy! She responded quickly, gave detailed explanation, answered all of my questions, and made purchasing insurance effortless! I will definitely pass her information along to anyone in need of all insurance’s. HIGHLY RECOMMEND to all!

We absolutely love Shayna Carnevale and cannot recommend her enough! She’s always ready and willing to help with all of our insurance needs. Shayna takes the time to walk us through every step, ensuring that all options are explored thoroughly. We recommend her to everyone we know, whether they need insurance or just have insurance-related questions. She is always prompt in getting back to us, and her customer service is top-notch

Shayna, made sure I got the best value one car insurance. She is very thorough and knowledgeable.  I would highly recommend her.

Shayna is an outstanding insurance agent! From the very beginning, she impressed us with her professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to helping us find the perfect coverage for our needs. She patiently explained every detail, making sure we fully understood our options and felt confident in our choices!

Shayna provides exceptional customer service! She was always quick to respond to our questions, provided thoughtful recommendations, and made the entire process seamless. It's clear she genuinely cares about her clients and goes above and beyond to ensure they’re taken care of.

We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy and reliable insurance agent. She’s the best!

As a business owner, you want someone you can trust to give you the best advice regarding insurance coverage for business and individual coverage.

Shayna went above and beyond in answering all of my questions and even followed back up with me making sure that I was satisfied.

Thank You Shayna!!

I’m very impressed with Shayna’s professionalism and effectiveness. Not only she found the best deal for my needs, but she also explained everything in the language that is understandable. Everything was finalized in a matter of hours. I highly recommend her services.

Shayna is always professional and knowledgeable. She’s provided the best service I could’ve asked for over the last 15 years.

As an exceptional insurance professional, Shayna Carnevale has guided me since 2020, when I was first navigating property ownership as a young adult; she was (and still is!) a steadfast presence and provided expert insurance advice and counsel.  Even now, four years later, I can readily call Shayna and know she will respond 24/7 and advocate lower rates and stronger policies for me.  In addition to her veteran knowledge and integrity, Shayna is an equally kind and conscientious person who truly cares for her clients.

I contacted Shayna Carnevale about getting pet insurance for our new puppy. I had a lot of questions for her, as I knew nothing about Pet insurance. Shayna was very helpful. She is very knowledgeable about coverage and options and was able to answer all my questions. It was a pleasure to deal with Shayna and feel satisfied with our decision to go with Hartville Pet Insurance. I will recommend Shayna to help others who need insurance.

Shayna is a person who makes you believe in Integrity again.....in this pretty crazy world.  I trust her completely, based on my experience with her.  She's literally the best agent I have every had for auto and home insurance.

Shayna was quick to answer amy questions. She took the time needed to look for the best fit for us and used all her connections to help us. You will get exactly what you need and more in mist cases. Thanks Shana!!!

I had such a great experience having Shayna and Elie assisted me in my search for a life insurance. I think the patience, personalized service, availability and constant follow up help make that successful team I would recommend to anyone looking for great professional assistance.

My family has been using Shayna for many years! She is always quick with a response and we’re so grateful for her time and abilities!

I've had the pleasure of working with Shayna for my personal home and auto insurance needs. My experience with her has been nothing short of exceptional, prompting me to refer her services to not just my clients but also to my closest family and friends. The unanimous feedback I've received only echoes my sentiments, Shayna is unparalleled in her field.

What sets her apart is not just her profound knowledge of the insurance industry but her innate ability to demystify its complexities. She approaches each conversation with patience and clarity, ensuring that you're not just informed but also comfortable and confident in your decision. She possesses a rare talent for  addressing concerns, tailoring solutions, and ensuring that your coverage truly reflects your needs. Her dedication is evident in her willingness to take the time to understand each individual's unique situation, making her not just an advisor but a trusted ally.

I wholeheartedly appreciate her exceptional service, combined with her genuine care for her clients, which makes her stand out as a beacon of reliability and trustworthiness in the insurance industry.

To anyone reading, if you haven't guessed it yet, if you are considering options for insurance, I highly recommend Shayna.  Meeting her has been one of the best decisions for my peace of mind regarding insurance matters. Shayna, thank you for everything you've done for me and those I've referred to you.

Shayna's great to work with -- she's helped my property owners looking for home owner's insurance and tenants looking for renter's insurance. I think she even helped a tenant get pet insurance for their dog. She's very thorough and will find a policy that fits.

I am so glad that I was able to find Shayna. She was very responsible and responsive throughout the process of getting a life insurance; very helpful, patient and knowledgeable about life insurance and the right policy for me and family.

Shayna is always available to answer a question or assist with our insurance. Wonderful to work with!

Shayna saved us $1062 in car insurance with better coverage than we had. She is knowledgeable,  attentive, engaging, great with follow up and just a great human being.  Grateful to her.  No brainer.... CALL HER.

I have referred clients of mine over the years and she has always done a great job.
.

I couldn’t be happier with the service and care Shayna provides.   It’s never been about making the sale, it’s more about keeping the relationship- the long term goal.   Anyone can provide insurance coverage but only Shayna can be your insurance quarterback!

Shayna's dedication to serving your best interests is unmatched. No question will go unanswered and all of your insurance needs will always be met, at the most affordable rate possible. Not only am I comfortable using Shayna myself, I am comfortable with her assisting my family, friends, and all my clients.

Shayna is the best! Came to me highly recommend and she did not disappoint. Always responded timely and navigated me through a foreign experience quickly and stress free. Can not say enough great things about my overall experience!

Exceptional service! Shayna is highly knowledgeable, efficient, and I wholeheartedly recommend her for top-notch insurance support.

Shayna is excellent. She is very personable and has your best interest in mind.  Very happy with insurance experiences with her.  She is professional, thorough, and timely in responding. Recommend giving her your business!!

Shayna is a top notch insurance agent.  She is professional, thorough and completes things in a timely manner.  I highly recommend!

Shayna is the best. I've been a Realtor for over 10 years and know so many insurance agents but Shayna is hands down the best. I refer her to all my clients.

Shayna is a true professional, she goes above and beyond for her clients to provide them with savings and value for your insurance needs. 5 Stars!!!!!!

Shayna has been great helping us with all of our insurance needs. She is attentive, responsive, and so personable. 10/10 would recommend!

Shayna is wonderful to work with. A few years ago, I had uncovered major damage to my home caused by my neighbors house. Unfortunately my previous insurance carrier had cut rate policy that didn’t cover my claim. Shayna helped me kick them to the curb & find a better carrier & policy to protect my home. I have both auto and homeowners policies with her. I look forward to working with her in the future when I move.

Shayna was very helpful with my questions and request. Very glad we started business with her.

Big thank you to Mrs. Rochelle Nelson who made my life change. forex/bitcoin trade is really a complex one but with the help of Mrs. Rochelle Nelson strategy, I have been able to recover my lost in such a short while with just an investment and i was sure to withdraw within the week of my investment and it was wonderful.
Contact now on
Email:rochellenelson571@gmail.com
WhatsApp:+13016159610
BACKUP On:
facebook"Rochelle Nelson

Shayna, was awesome to work with. She was professional, diligent & beyond helpful in getting my husband and I the best auto & homeowners policies. She made the process seamless for us. We give Shayna the highest  recommendation :)

Improve your cryptocurrency with a trusted account manager it's what can make your dreams come through. For me Mrs Rochelle Nelson has the best trading strategies to win. I never believed on any post recommending online trading until I gave her a try and the outcome was great for me. I made a whole lot of profit....! I invested $1,000 to earn $12,000.
I recommend her to anyone looking to earn in Crypto through her via 
Email: Email:rochellenelson731@gmail.com
facebook"Rochelle Nelson
WhatsApp:+13016159610

Shayna is a pleasure to do business with and made finding insurance for my needs easy.

Shayna was great help, when I was deciding on our pet insurance.  Thanks!

Always have been eager to invest in this forex and binary investment but don't know how to go about it not until i met a recommendation which recommended this MRS MORRIS BERTHA who helped manage and made good profit on Binary and Forex investments so I collected his information then contacted him to know how I can also benefit from this also, he explained all I needed to know about forex/binary investments, so I started with just $1000 after 7days i earn profit of $12,500 when i gave it a try and it worked out for me successfully, today I and my family are doing perfectly fine all thanks to MRS MORRIS BERTHA, if you wish to invest then you can easily do that with he management they are the best, you can contact email MorrisBertha45@gmail.com 
WhatsApp:  +1 (747) 201-7724

Shayna is so sweet, caring and just a wonderful agent to have the pleasure of dealing with. I would absolutely refer friends and family to her trusting that they would be in good hands. Highly recommend.

She is wonderful.  Very thorough and caring.  She will do her best to get you great coverage at a great price.

I started this year having nothing just a small business of mine which was not improving until I saw a review earlier last week about a fantastic, honest, legit, and professional FX trader Mrs KAYLA WILLIAMS and decided to take the risk with more confidence and contacted her and first I funded my account with just $1,000 and within a week I got $11,350 amazing service you get from an amazing trader like Mrs KAYLA WILLIAMS, now I have more than enough to spend on my family, all thanks to Kayla Williams. contact her now with no hesitation.
Email: kaylawilliamsfx@gmail.com
WhatsApp: +1 (864) 777-0838

Shayna has been absolutely fantastic as an agent. She is also extremely down to earth and cares deeply about her customers and values them. Recently, Shayna helped me with both my car and home owners insurance policies. Not only did she save me boatloads of money, she went above and beyond even assisting me with contacting my mortgage company to ensure payment was sent so that I had the best coverage ASAP. Shayna is a customer advocate and shows in her actions. I would highly recommend her!

Shayna Carnevale

Comparion Executive Agent | Philadelphia, PA

Quote with Shayna

Hours

Location

100 E Penn Square
Suite 433
Philadelphia, PA 19107

About me

Licensed in

Connecticut - 15886348

Delaware - 1117761

Florida - W708895

Massachusetts - 15886348

Maryland - 3000205997

Services

Car insurance

Home insurance

Umbrella insurance

Life insurance

Insurance consulting

Languages

English

Education

Masters Degree from Thomas Jefferson University

Qualifications

LUTCF

Awards & Honors

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Countrywide Rookie of the year

President's Club

Shayna Carnevale

Comparion Executive Agent | Philadelphia, PA

Quote with Shayna

Hours

Location

100 E Penn Square Suite 433 Philadelphia, PA 19107

About me

Licensed in

Connecticut - 15886348

Delaware - 1117761

Florida - W708895

Massachusetts - 15886348

Maryland - 3000205997

Services

Car insurance

Home insurance

Umbrella insurance

Life insurance

Insurance consulting

Languages

English

Education

Masters Degree from Thomas Jefferson University

Qualifications

LUTCF

Awards & Honors

Liberty Leaders

Liberty Life Leaders

Lamplighter Award

Countrywide Rookie of the year

President's Club

100 E Penn Square
Suite 433
Philadelphia, PA 19107